The Prepared Pantry

Old Fashioned Buttermilk Syrup Mix Limit 1!

Ah, a caramel syrup with a touch of butterscotch.

SKU: PP302
-67%
$1.99 $5.99you save $4.00

 

  • What is buttermilk syrup? It's syrup made with buttermilk.
  • How does that work? Buttermilk is very sour and very acidic.  We take the acid out of it so that it doesn't taste like buttermilk anymore.
  • How do you do that? It's magic. Actually, we neutralize the acid.
  • What does it taste like then? The acid is gone, so you don't have any of that acidy taste.
  • Is it tart? No, not at all. It's smooth and mellow.  There's a slight butterscotch, but it is so faint that most people don't notice it.  It's a little bit sweet because of the lactose, a form of sugar.  
  • Do you add caramel? We do have a little bit of flavor but mostly, you're tasting the caramel. Cooking butter and sugar together makes caramel.
  • So it's mostly a caramel syrup? Yes, mostly. You'll pick up a little of that butterscotch tone and a little vanilla, but it's a caramel syrup.
  • How do I know when it's cooked? It changes to a caramel color. It doesn't take long and it's dependable.
  • What happens if I keep cooking it? It turns into caramel candy.
  • When I start cooking it, it makes lots of bubbles. What's that? It's us doing our magic, neutralizing the acid.  Make sure that you have a big enough pan that it doesn't boil over.
  • How much syrup does it make? Two cups.
  • What do I add? Butter and water.

 

This is your family's new favorite syrup--better than maple. The taste is incredible, and you can use it in so many ways--not just pancakes! 

"WOW, this pancake syrup is good! It would be good on ice cream or apple crisp, as well as pancakes. And if the truth is known, I thought of eating the little leftover like soup. I can't believe how good this stuff is!!  Melanie M.

"I love this syrup! You can use it on EVERYTHING. I use it to top my Aebelskivers and German pancakes. This is now a household staple at our house. Thank you, Prepared Pantry. No more boring maple in our house.)" Melissa D

This is your every weekend syrup. It will make you a hero. Read the reviews. Then stock up.

Bakers' tip: You don't need to time it. Just stir so that it doesn't scorch, and cook it until it turns a beautiful caramel color. That's your timer! It's like magic. It won't take long.

Look what others say!

  • "Great for gifts." Meledie Knopf
  • "Not too sweet, just perfect." Carol Blaha
  • "It's a great flavor but not maple."  Lorena
  • "Everyone loved it."  Jolene Hurst
  • "My favorite syrup!"  Barbara Anderson
  • "Really good on many things." Sheila Stuart
  • "Was I in for a treat!" Diane Stowe
  • "A regular favorite." Sheila
  • "My new syrup!"  Suzanne Jackson
  • "You can use it on EVERYTHING!"  Mellisa D.

Give it a try. Breakfast will never be the same at your house.

 

Ingredients: Sugar, dry buttermilk, corn syrup, baking soda, and natural and artificial flavors.

 

Customer Reviews

Based on 43 reviews
91%
(39)
5%
(2)
0%
(0)
0%
(0)
5%
(2)
R
RaNae Miller

I’ve bought it many times. We love it! I just wish the system would let me buy more than 1 when I order.

J
Jeanne Brunelle
Buttermilk Syrup Mix

WOW. Excellent quality. Easy to use.

M
Mary T

Yummy the best!💐

C
Chauncey Haight
Great products for the occasional baker

I really like the mixes. They give you excellent results without a lot of hassle. They make me look like I know how to bake.

R
Renee Landon
Best syrup

My kids call this the candy syrup, it’s rich and the perfect complimentary treat for your pancakes. We only buy prepared pantry syrup, it’s the best!