How to Make Unforgettable Hamburger Buns
The bun makes the burger. A homemade hamburger bun is way better than a commercial one. There is no comparison. But you can go even further; make buns with fancy, flavorful breads. Now you’re getting there. Homemade is better than store-bought. Jalapeño cheddar buns and their cousins are better than white. We have over sixty kinds of bread, but our favorites for hamburger buns are:
- Diego’s Jalapeno Cheese Bread
- Cheesy Salsa Bread
- Black Russian Bread/ Pumpernickel Bread
- Sour Cream Onion Bread
The quest for the perfect hamburger.
It's two hours and three minutes from where we live in Rigby, Idaho, to Dillon, Montana, across the Continental Divide, and back again makes it four hours. And yes, one Saturday afternoon, Merri Ann and I drove to Sparky's Garage in Dillon, Montana, for hamburgers and fries. Crazy.
Now Sparky's is a fun place to eat. It has vintage vehicles in the dining room. You can order and eat your burger from the bed of an old pick-up.
Sparky's has great hamburgers, with maybe even precision patties. But they haven’t discovered unforgettable buns. We’ll cover both.
How to Cook Precision Hamburger Patties
You want precision patties cooking on your grill. If they’re not precision, they’re not the same and if they’re not the same, they won’t cook the same. The skinny ones cook faster than the thick ones.
You want the meat compressed so it holds together on the grill. You want it compressed enough that it captures the juices through cooking. But if you compress it too much, you’ll have a hocky puck, certainly not tender.
The best way to make precision patties is with a hamburger press. Start with the same amount of meat for each. We use a scale, weighing each mound of meat precisely. A quarter pound of meat will make quarter-pound patties. You may prefer a third pound of meat, a little thicker than ¼-inch.
If you don’t have a scale, use measuring cups. A 1/3-cup measure will get just over a quarter pounder.
Press the meat each time with the same pressure to get the same thickness. Watch the juices. You’ll have a little juice running from your patties, but just a little.
Cook them the same. Get the heat right and put all the patties on the grill at once. When they’re ready, turn them all together and turn them once. You lose juice on every turn. Don’t press down on the burgers with a spatula. You’ll lose juice when you do. You want juicy burgers.
How will you tell if they’re done? You can use a thermometer, but in a thin piece of meat, that’s not very precise. Experience. I use my finger. An old chef taught me that when I was a much younger lad. Meat gets firmer as it cooks. Rare meat is soft.
I was working a grill, which meant lots of steaks. He worked with me until I could tell medium from medium rare just by poking it with my finger. You’ll learn with experience. Try to use the same amount of heat each time. A timer might help.
Now, cooking burger patties doesn’t have to be exacting. It’s an art more than a science. But being consistent does matter. Your burgers will be consistently better. And you will become better and better at burgers.
Get the hamburger press.

This is Eight Mile Pool near Leadore, Idaho, not far from the Lewis and Clark trail. It’s quiet and still, peaceful and alone. Brightly colored rainbow trout live in those shadows. (Image by Merri Ann Weaver)
__________________________
Okay, now you know what precision patties are, why they’re important. Let’s move on to buns.
These use Cheesy Salsa Bread Mix and our Black Russian Bread/ Pumpernickel Bread Machine Mix to make some truly unique burger buns.
You can make these buns using your bread machine or with a stand-type mixer. Here are the directions for making buns with a bread machine.
- Mix the bread according to the package directions or recipe.
- Using a bench scraper or sharp knife, divide the dough into eight equal pieces.
- Form each piece into a ball. Pull the dough around the center and pinch the seam at the bottom of the roll.
- Place each ball of dough onto a greased or parchment paper lined baking sheet. Using the back of your hand, flatten each ball into a disc. Because the dough has a tendency to spring back, repeat this process after a few minutes.
- Make sure you let these buns rise covered (preferably in a proofing bag) in a warm area. Let them rise until doubled in size. If you have a cool kitchen, it will take an hour or more. When it has risen enough, you will air bubbles just beginning to form under the dough skin. If blister start to form on the dough, pop the blisters with the point of a knife and hurry your buns to the oven.
- Bake at 350 degrees until the interior temperature reaches 190 degrees or until the tops are golden.
Remove the buns from the baking sheet immediately and let them cool on a wire rack. Once cooled, you’re ready to assemble some beautiful burgers!

Hamburger buns made with Sour Cream Onion Rolls bread mix
Dennis Weaver
Comments (0)
There are no comments for this article. Be the first one to leave a message!