The Prepared Pantry

Old-Fashioned Snickerdoodle Cookies

These are five-star snickerdoodles--better than the local cookie store.

SKU: C145-1
$5.98 $5.99you save $0.01
  • Are these just regular snickerdoodles? Well, they're traditional snickerdoodles. We tried several recipes, and this is the one we liked best.
  • What do other people say? A local cookie store owner approached us and asked if she could buy our mix in bulk. "I can't make snickerdoodles as good as yours."
  • What about the customers? This is a five-star product. Out of 29 reviews, 28 are five-star reviews. The last one seems like she overbaked them. Cookies bake quickly, and ovens vary. Check the first batch before the time is up--the bottoms should be golden, not brown.
  • What makes them better? Other than the recipe, I think it's the cinnamon.  We use a good grade of cinnamon with a high cinnamon oil content.
  • What type of cinnamon? It's Extra Select Korintje Cassia Cinnamon.
  • How many cookies does it make? Each mix makes thirty-six 2 1/2-inch cookies.
  • That's a lot of cookies. Can I freeze the extras? You can. You can also freeze the dough.  Make the little rough dough balls and freeze them. When you get ready to bake them, thaw the dough and then roll them through the cinnamon sugar mixture. 

Dennis Weaver

You cannot make great snickerdoodles without great cinnamon! The most important ingredient in snickerdoodles is the cinnamon. 

You won't find snickerdoodles made with cinnamon that is this good elsewhere. Grocery stores and volume bakeries are very competitive. They sell on cost. And really good cinnamon is just too expensive. But really good cinnamon makes a magical difference.

"The best that I have tasted."  Marsha Crosby 

"So delicious! I will never buy store-bought cookies again."  Donna Thornton

 Make them for your family. Your family deserves really good snickerdoodles. They will love these.

—Featured Review—

"I love snickerdoodles, but I’ve never been able to achieve the taste and texture of your mix." Mary Lou Mattingly

Customer Reviews

Based on 29 reviews
Karen Weaver


Sheri Vincent

Old-Fashioned Snickerdoodle Cookies

Larry Biddinger
Great cookies

We really enjoyed them as did the grandkids, quite good

Pamela Pyle
Snickerdoodle cookies

I love the snickerdoodle cookies my son loves the snickerdoodle cookies at his favorite cookies my son, my husband doesn’t care too much for snickerdoodles, but he really liked those. They’re soft they’re easy to make and I enjoyed them fully. Thank you so much.

Julie Maeser

Ive told others how easy and delicious these cookies are. I've told them to stock up so in an emergency when you have to take a treat somewhere, you will be the hit of the party.